Rand Simberg has a wonderful fisking of unrependent CBS producer Mary Mapes’ self-serving new book. Mapes’ head is bloody, but unbowed.
Simberg’s post is very very funny. Mapes herself, on the other hand, makes me very very sad, and very very angry. Her statements are so illogical that she makes me wonder whether any sort of critical thinking at all is required for a job as a producer with CBS. Perhaps not.
Mapes writes, among other things:
I was told that the first posting claiming the documents were fakes had gone up on Free Republic before our broadcast was even off the air!
Anyone who has followed the story knows that the theory of the early posting has been totally discredited by the fact that it involves a confusion between time zones. So Mary either doesn’t grasp the time zone concept, or she is disingenuous in using the covering phrase “I was told.” Either way, not good.
Mapes also writes:
There was no analysis of what the documents actually said, no work done to look at the content, no comparison with the official record, no phone calls made to check the facts of the story, nothing beyond a cursory and politically motivated examination of the typeface. That was all they had to attack, but that was enough.
Yes, Mary, let me try to explain it to you: ordinarily, when a document is proven fake, that fact automatically discredits its contents (some of the comments on the Simberg thread are hilarious along this vein). Mapes seems unable to grasp that simple concept–or perhaps she hopes that we will be unable to grasp it.
Is Mapes stupid, or is she ignorant–or is she banking on the fact that we are stupid and ignorant?